Conservative Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito recently voiced concern about the diminishing support for freedom of speech, particularly on university campuses. Delivering a commencement address at the Franciscan University of Steubenville in Ohio, he stressed the importance of safeguarding the exchange of ideas in such settings, which he believes are vital for fostering diverse perspectives.
Alito's comments seemed to reference the unrest seen on numerous campuses, often triggered by protests against various issues, including Israel's military actions in Gaza. He observed that while the Franciscan University embodies the ideal of free speech, many other institutions fall short of this standard.
Despite Alito's advocacy for free speech, he has also stressed the need for limits. In a 2011 case involving the Westboro Baptist Church's protests at a military veteran's funeral, Alito dissented in an 8-1 ruling affirming the group's free speech rights. He argued that such protection should not cover what he described as "vicious verbal assault."
Alito, a Catholic, has frequently expressed concerns about religious freedom and has consistently voted to expand religious rights. Speaking to the graduating students, he cautioned them about potential challenges to their beliefs in the outside world, urging them to remain firm in their convictions.
Alito's remarks come at a time when the Supreme Court is expected to issue rulings on several contentious issues, including abortion, gun rights, and the legal matters surrounding former President Donald Trump's actions following the 2020 election. Fellow conservative Justice Clarence Thomas also recently spoke out about facing criticism and "nastiness" during a judicial conference in Alabama, while Justice Brett Kavanaugh emphasized the long-term impact of unpopular rulings, suggesting they can become integral to American constitutional law over time.